Tobias Butler, founder of Tuneshine

Tobias Butler is the founder of Tuneshine, the Oakland company behind a square LED display that lights up your room with the album art of whatever you’re listening to. A lifelong musician who has always tinkered with software, Tobias studied music in college, spent much of his career as a software engineer at Change.org, and built the first Tuneshine at home in 2020 out of Home Depot wood and a Raspberry Pi. He still answers every customer email himself.

A Tuneshine display showing album art on a marble kitchen counter beside a cutting board and a bowl of fruit

01 Origin. What problem, frustration, or quiet conviction made your company or product necessary? Take us back to the moment the idea wouldn't leave you alone.

It was essentially once I had it on my own desk. It was one of those moments where you initially build a product for yourself and you realize, oh, this is actually really great. I love having this thing around.

In addition to just the mechanics of it (you listen to music and it shows the album art), you start to realize these subtle ways that it changes the experience of listening to music. It affects your recall a little bit. Sometimes you’ll be hearing a song and you’ll be like, “Oh, what band is this again?” And then you look over at the album art. Or you’ll be listening to a playlist and realize that you’re much more grounded in how the artists are changing. Instead of having the potential to blend together, it gives you more of an appreciation that these are a bunch of different artists being combined in this way.

It helps give your music a focal point in the room. The sound is all around you, but you can point to it and say, “That is the music, that is what’s playing.” It looks cool, and I think the fact that it has a borderless design gets people excited. But as I lived with it, I realized there are a lot of unexpected things here that I think are really cool. Seeing the response from people I know made me realize, “Okay, I might not be the only one.” After that I thought, “If I were ever going to start a company in my life, this seemed like a good one to do.”

A Tuneshine on a wooden desk beside a laptop, its album art matching the song playing on a phone

02 What you were doing before. What were you doing before this, and how did it prepare you, or fail to prepare you, for what you're building now?

I’ve always been a musician, and I’ve always been someone who’s tinkered with software. When I was in my early teens, I just thought the internet was super cool. I loved that you could build a webpage and instantly show it off to people, so I ended up learning programming from wanting to make more interesting webpages. Once I got to college, I realized there’s a whole discipline where you get to learn software. I didn’t go in with a strong sense of what I wanted to do as a career. I ended up being a music major and also did most of a computer science degree, and I’ve kept those two things a big part of my life to this day.

I was never really doing music on the work side. I worked at a couple of small tech startups and then spent a lot of my career at Change.org as a software engineer, helping create social change around the world. I worked with a lot of really interesting people in many different countries and loved the team there.

When I was stuck at home in 2020, I started buying different electronics parts, and one of the things I was messing around with was an LED display. Square displays are kind of weird. They’re too narrow for certain things and not tall enough for others. But then I realized that album art was the perfect size and shape for it. Once I built that, I posted it on my Instagram and got a good response from my friends. If I was ever going to get a strong sign that I should start a company, this would be it.

It really did just start as a home project. I’ve still got one of the originals that I made at home: wood from Home Depot, a Raspberry Pi inside, and screws all over the place. Because I come from the software industry, a lot of the ways people typically do hardware (the Kickstarters, the fundraising, the large MOQs) weren’t very familiar to me. So, I worked the way I knew how to work, which is to test something small and see what happens. That led me to building 50 of them, then 100, then 200, and then about 300 at a time. It took about nine months before I got really sick of building them at home, but it was a pretty valuable experience. I still stand by the approach of doing what I know, trying things small, and—once it works—figuring out the next step.

Tobias at his home workstation, monitoring Tuneshine dashboards on a wide screen

03 The constraint that shaped it. Every well-made object is defined as much by what it isn't as what it is. What was the hardest constraint you worked within, and how did it sharpen the final product?

I get challenged a lot, both by people asking me questions and by competing products taking a different approach. But I’ve always felt a strong conviction that keeping it really music-focused is important to the core experience. Over time, I’ve gotten requests like, “Can you add weather, can you add stocks?” There are products that do that, and I think they’re great. It’s a different philosophy. Those products tend to work for people who want information to be even more present in their lives and in their homes, and I’ve never really felt that way. I used to wear an Apple Watch, and at some point after I started working from home, I just thought, this is not necessary. I’m already close enough to all of the things I could possibly want to know.

So, I’ve built this conviction that focusing on music is the right move and will make it a stronger product for music lovers, even if I’m missing out on people who want music and other things too. Those other products are never going to be able to do the music part as well because music can be a lot harder. You want it to respond more or less instantly when a new song comes on, which isn’t as important for stock prices and weather. And there are a lot of different music systems. Many of these products only work over the cloud, but a lot of people listen through devices in their homes that aren’t reachable over the cloud. If you’ve built a product with that assumption in mind, you can’t reach certain musical setups. Or you might not think to add a Shazam feature to the app so that even if you’re putting on a record, Tuneshine can show it.

There’s a lot of depth to the way people listen to music. It’s pretty rare that someone says, I have my preferred weather service and need this to work with it. With music, people are much more particular. The conviction has kind of paid off because it’s let me dig really deep and support a market that gets more fragmented as you get into higher-end setups. If I can reach a few more people who say, “I care so much about music that I picked this very specific thing, and I’m so glad Tuneshine works with it,” then I think that’s great.

Tobias assembling a Tuneshine, fitting the wood enclosure to an LED matrix panel

04 A design decision you defended. Walk us through one choice that was questioned, debated, or pushed back on, and why you held the line.

The wood case. It’s not really a frame because it doesn’t go around the display; it’s the enclosure that attaches to the back. Wood is pretty hard to work with. You put it on a boat, and it goes across the ocean; it can be humid out there, and sometimes things warp a little bit. They’ll shrink in one direction but not the other. You get a lower yield because the wood is just going to move. But it looks super nice, and I’ve stuck with it because it’s part of the overall experience of a tech product that’s meant to feel unexpected and very unlike other tech products.

If you have an iPad set up in your living room to control your smart home stuff and your music, that can be very useful, but I don’t think anyone would ever walk in and think, “That is so cool, this person has an iPad in their living room.” I really want people to look at this and say, “That is cool, that is different from what I’ve seen before.”

In some ways, it’s good that it feels like furniture because there are a lot of great things about furniture. People see it as a more timeless thing, something that’s going to last a long time, and they don’t really ask a lot of it. Sometimes people will say, “If I’m not playing music, then the Tuneshine is useless; it’s not doing anything.” And I just think, well, so are your speakers. So is a chair. You still look at these things, so it’s important that they look nice. But people have been trained to expect that something should be giving them something to pay attention to all the time, and I think that’s very fatiguing. Building something that fits more into the living room setting signals to you that it can just be an object, and that’s okay. Just let it sit there, and it will have its time.

That’s why I haven’t made a plastic version, even though it would make my life easier in a lot of ways. I always want to imagine someone walking into the room and instantly asking, “What is that? That is different from anything I’ve seen before.” The wood helps do that a lot.

Tuneshine wood enclosures, front and back

05 What you removed. Form and Function lives in what's left after the cuts. What did you take out, leave on the cutting room floor, or refuse to add?

The temptation to do a higher-resolution screen. There are not a ton, but there are square LCD displays out there, and a lot of people will pop up and say, “I would buy this if it were higher resolution.” I understand that. But there’s that iPad factor again—you want to be different from a form we already feel familiar with. And in terms of selling this as a product, if you put a high-res screen on a niche product made in smaller batches, you might get stuck inviting comparisons to tablets. People could say, “For this price, I can buy a tablet.” And they’re totally right. For a lot of people, I’ll just straight up tell them, “It sounds like what you actually want is a tablet, and you should get one. I don’t think this product is necessarily right for you.”

It’s not a super cheap product. The other stuff in this space typically gets the cost down by doing a plastic case or a screen with half the number of pixels. A lot of them use 64 by 32 displays instead of 64 by 64. But the key is keeping it feeling like a totally different experience from the computing devices we see around us. What I usually end up telling people is, “If there’s ever a way to do it without bezels around the screen, I might jump on that because that form factor works very well for album art.” It helps evoke the idea that this image is not just an image; it’s evocative of an object. If a record sleeve is sitting in your living room, it’s not going to have a frame around it. It’s just that image, edge to edge. Being able to replicate that is more important than a high-res display. If you have a text-heavy album cover, yes, you’ll be able to read things on a high-res display that you can’t read at all on a low-res LED display. But in terms of the overall philosophy of the product, the low-res display ends up fitting a lot better.

I think our brains do something when we look at a high-resolution screen where it’s impossible for us to see it as an object. Screens are incredible. It’s crazy that we can do that. But we’re so used to them that we end up looking through them and only seeing what’s in them, even though it’s this magical effect. Decontextualizing that a little bit, having the pixels be visible and more tangible, and removing the borders makes you able to see it more as an object rather than a portal for information and distractions and responsibilities. It’s just showing different colors, and your mind is constructing an image. That’s a cool effect, and it’s far enough from the usual response to a screen that you feel it a little more viscerally.

06 A make-or-break moment. Walk us through a moment you weren't sure you'd make it through. What got you to the other side?

I’d say I’ve been feeling that a bit lately. Partially, it’s because the online picture (Meta ads in particular) changed a lot. A lot of people have been struggling with that in the last year. It used to be a much more reliable source of new customers, and this year it’s been a little rough. That’s required me to figure out how to work in a different way and find those people in different ways.

Some of that has been going back to the product and saying, “Okay, I’m going to find new people by building new capabilities and integrating more music services.” And then I go to those people and tell them, “Hey, this is new, this works for you now, check it out.” I’m also getting some outside help to lean more into organic social media. When I used to build them at home, that was kind of a goldmine for really interesting videos and images showing the process. Now that they’re not being made at home, it’s harder to get that day-in-the-life stuff working because it’s just a lot less visually compelling.

I’m at this moment where I’ve been investing in new strategies and new ways to reach people, and a lot of that is still ramping up. I might be hit with a hard lesson in a couple of months, or that pivot could end up being successful. It’s been a challenging year full of marketing lessons, and I’m in the middle of figuring it out right now. But I know the people are out there. I’m nowhere near the ceiling of the people who want to know about this and want to get this.

07 Who you look at. Whose work do you look at when you need to remember why you started? What brands, designers, or thinkers shape how you see things?

A lot of the inspiration does come from artists. Something that’s always inspired me is going to a craft fair where people have their own personal style and make a lot of pieces by hand. You walk around; something catches your eye at a booth; and then you get to meet the person who makes these things. I’ve always felt it would be really cool to have a tech product that feels like that.

So much of the design of technology feels pretty homogeneous, and you don’t get as many cases where a gadget is built by someone saying, “This is my work, this is my vision that I’m realizing for you.” People just aren’t used to doing the marketing for their own product that way, and as a consumer, you’re not used to seeing a product like that. Where you do see some of it is in higher-end audio equipment and in the instrument world: bespoke synthesizers or guitar companies where the products are named after the person who conceived them. For synthesizers in particular, there’s a lot more of a culture of people doing these smaller-batch, more artisanal-feeling products.

A lot of that is just marketing, but you have to back it up in a certain way. So, I do all the customer support for Tuneshine as well, and my email signature says “Tobias, creator of Tuneshine” because I know that’s really refreshing and just something people don’t expect from a tech product. I really look up to the industries where that kind of thing is a lot more common.

08 What's next, and what stays the same? Where is the brand going from here, and what will never change about how you make things?

What will never change is the music focus. Music is one of the most important things in my life, and I think that’s true for so many people, musicians and music listeners alike. It’s a core part of people’s identity, and it’s gotten a bit harder to express that and show the people around you. It used to be more common to walk into someone’s house and see their music collection right there, and you could browse and get to know them. I love when you get to be at someone’s house and see what records and books are on their shelf. You don’t get that with streaming, except once a year when everyone posts their Spotify Wrapped, and people really love that because they crave a way to express themselves. That’s why people are buying 13 versions of one Taylor Swift album. Without music taking up physical space in our homes by necessity, you’re buying band shirts and taking Instagram photos at concerts. I don’t think any of that is better or worse than physical media. It’s an expression of the same craving: this is me, I want to show this to you because it’s so important to me. I don’t think that’s going away, and I think Tuneshine offers people that form of self-expression.

As with any product, once you sell a bunch of them, the things that happen one in 100 times are happening constantly, and the things that happen one in 1,000 times start being more frequent too. So, I started getting some outside engineering help, and right now I’m really just trying to make the product as stable as possible, both physically and in terms of software. I’ve got a slightly updated case design coming soon that should be a little sturdier and offer a little more flexibility in how you can put it in your home, but it keeps the core experience the same. It’ll look exactly the same from the front.

It’s the kind of product where the people who really get it understand they shouldn’t expect radical changes. I’m not going to roll out an all-new experience and reimagine the product because at its core it’s intentionally supposed to be a little unobtrusive. It isn’t trying to grab your attention in a serious way. It’s mostly just trying to add a little extra joy to your life if you’re someone who already loves music. It’s so satisfying when I talk to people who bought it and really get that, and they say, “Oh, I love that it only does one thing. It’s so refreshing.” So, a lot of what I do is just find those people, show them what I’ve got, and see if they want to bring it into their homes.

09 Who's next? Name one or two founders, makers, or studios making products that beautifully marry form and function right now. Someone we should be paying attention to, and why.

A couple of people are making super interesting products and are also just really good people (people I’ve gotten to talk to). They share this kind of personal philosophy.

There’s a company called Nanu. Hanna and Andrew are super cool. I’ve gone over to their studio, and we ended up just chatting for hours. It’s super fun to see how they work differently. Because they come from the industrial design world, they’re much more comfortable with, “Yeah, we’re going to do a Kickstarter, build the hype, and then deliver the product.” It’s a clock with a physical chime that sounds completely delightful. I think that’s such an interesting constraint to work with. They figured out such a nice way to do it, and it’s so evident how much care they put into it.

The other one is Livegrid. Dhruv is based in the UK, and I just love how wacky and artistic his product is. It’s essentially a virtual aquarium, and you can see the health of the aquarium because it reflects the current indoor air quality in your home. He’s built all these virtual fish and animals and plants swimming around. It’s super captivating, but it also has this hidden meaning. It’s a totally different take on what I talked about earlier—people wanting information in more places in their homes. It’s such a cool thing to say: “I do want this information because I don’t know what the air quality is in my home and none of my current devices tell me; how could we make that fun and exciting and something I’d be really proud to hang on my wall?” I’m so glad he’s finding people who are into this delightfully weird idea.

I love when something weird can just grab people like that. Cell phones used to be so weird, and you’d see these interesting phone designs and think, “That is strange.” We don’t have that as much anymore, so I love it when something is really out there and is able to get people excited about it.

Tobias listening on headphones in a leather chair, a Tuneshine glowing on the shelf beside him

Lightning Round

An object you'd never replace

A ratcheting screwdriver. I love that satisfying click, and it just feels comfortable in the hand. Every time you go back to a non-ratcheting one you’re like, “Oh, this is such a pain.” Having a way to comfortably complete a mundane task can make it feel so much nicer.

A book, film, or album that shaped how you think about design

Drone Logic by Daniel Avery. It came out in 2013, and it’s more salient in my mind right now because I just saw him perform live. It’s dance music, kind of techno. Listening to it, I thought for a long time that he was adding something funny in there to create these sounds; I’d never heard anything like them. After listening for more than 10 years, I finally looked up how he does it. He wasn’t adding something on top. He was taking much more standard synthesizer sounds and finding little things within them to emphasize, creating new melodies and completely new textures by boosting little parts of what was already there. Maybe it’s a bit of a stretch, but it makes me want to see more gadgets that are just focused on bringing people joy: things that should be kind of obvious and easy to build, but that, put together in the right way, create something really unexpected and joyful out of things that were already there.

A daily ritual

Listening to music. It’s essential. My wife and I will have a lot of music on when we’re sitting on the couch reading or eating dinner. I just can’t imagine living without having music around.

The last thing you bought that surprised you

The Arc alarm clock. It’s got a strong philosophy, and the physical chime is just so nice. Maybe as a musician it feels extra special to have that, but it’s a really cool, fresh take on the alarm clock while still feeling very modern.

A piece of advice you'd give to someone making their first product

Make something that you won’t get tired of talking about every day. You want a match between your skills and what you’re building. If it’s got a lot of complex, fiddly hardware, you’re going to want hardware experience. If the hardware is simple and you can do a lot of it in software, software experience might be enough. But almost more important than that is finding something that you’ll never get bored talking about to your customers because they have the same interests you do, and you’re genuinely excited whenever they hit you up and say, “Look how I’m using this.” You’re going to be doing that all the time, so make sure the area of life your product fits into is something that’s really important to you.

Coffee order

I actually drink English breakfast tea mostly, but when I do get coffee, it’s always a cold brew.

About FORM & FUNCTION

Form & Function is a print magazine about the objects worth keeping. We write about the tools, gear, and everyday things that earn their place through good design and honest craft: the stuff that works as well as it looks. Each issue is made slowly and on purpose: matte pages, considered writing, no filler. This newsletter is where that same thinking shows up between issues, with founder interviews, early looks, and the occasional thing we can't stop thinking about.

Were you forwarded this?

Someone thought you'd like it, and they were probably right. If Form & Function feels like your kind of thing, consider subscribing. It's free, there’s a new founder feature every week, and it's the best way to get first word on new issues and everything we're making.

FORM & FUNCTION: Issue 002.

The quarterly print magazine about things worth keeping. Matte, printed, made to be held. Issue 002 launches in November.

Keep Reading

READ MORE
arrow-right